The SCL has published “Proof by Sampling after Amey LG v Cumbria County Council” – a paper presented by Frances Pigott to the Society of Construction Law at a meeting in London on 4 July 2017.
Does a claimant have to prove liability and quantum on every variation or defect claimed, or will proof of a sample suffice? Defendants face similar questions when defending claims, particularly where costs in the action are budget limited. In this paper, Frances Pigott reviews the TCC decision in Amey LG v Cumbria County Council and considers whether the judge’s finding on the use of sampling in that case might be applied more widely in construction cases, its effectiveness as a means of proving claims, whether sampling is cost efficient and the importance of pre-trial case management in the sampling process.
A full version of the paper is available on the SCL website.