Breakshore Ltd v Red Key Concepts Ltd [2022] 5 WLUK 677

13th Oct 2022

In Breakshore Ltd v Red Key Concepts Ltd [2022] 5 WLUK 677, Max Twivy acted for the successful claimant in resisting a Pt 8 claim challenging the correctness of an adjudication decision. The Pt 8 claim related to which party bore contractual responsibility for a breach of planning permission, and whether such a breach was an act of prevention which entitled the contractor to suspend its works.

The adjudication decision had awarded liquidated damages to the employer. The judgment considered the principles set out in Hutton v Wilson [2017] EWHC 517 (TCC) relating to Part 8 challenges to the enforcement of adjudication decisions. It was held that the issues of (a) whether it was reasonable for the contractor to suspend its works and (b) causation (whether the planning permission issue was in fact a cause of delay), were questions of fact which were not suitable for Part 8 proceedings. It was also held that declarations pursued in the Part 8 claim could not readily be separated from other declarations which the parties had agreed would be dealt with in Part 7 proceedings.

Costs were awarded on the indemnity basis, having regard to the adjudication enforcement regime and the inappropriate use of the Part 8 procedure.

Max Twivy (instructed by K&L Gates LLP) for the Claimant.

Paul Darling QC and David Hopkins (instructed by Shemmings Hathaway LLP) for the Defendant.

 

 





Related Juristictions

Cookie consent

This website uses cookies to collect information about how you use this website. Atkin Chambers uses this information to make the website work as well as possible and improve the services provided by members and staff. You may choose to accept all cookies or chose to manage your cookie settings here:

Cookies on atkinchambers.com

Cookies are files saved on your phone, tablet or computer when you visit a website.

Atkin Chambers uses this information to make the website work as well as possible and improve the services provided by members and staff. You may choose to accept all cookies or chose to manage your cookie settings here:

Cookie settings

Atkin Chambers Limited use two types of cookie files, analytical cookies and necessary cookies. You can choose which cookies you are happy for us to use.

Analytical cookies that measure website use

Atkin Chambers Limited use Google Analytics to measure how you use the website so it can be improved based on user needs. Atkin Chambers do not allow Google to use or share the data about how you use this site.

Google Analytics sets cookies that store anonymised information about:

  • how you got to the site
  • the pages you visit on atkinchambers.com, and how long you spend on each page
  • what you click on while you’re visiting the site

Strictly necessary cookies

These essential cookies do things like remember your progress through a form (for example if you register for updates). They always need to be on.

Save changes